New Brunswick diocese wins case over sex abuse payouts
In a decision that confirms its right to proactively reach out to victims of sexual abuse by priests, the Catholic Diocese of Bathurst, New Brunswick, has been awarded $3.4 million in a dispute with its insurance company.
Following the Oct. 18 decision by the New Brunswick Court of Appeal, the insurer, Aviva Canada, said it would take time to consider appealing to the Supreme Court of Canada. It has 60 days from the date of the decision.
The dispute centers around a case first heard in 2016 in which payments were made to more than 90 victims of predator priests covering a period of decades beginning in the 1950s.
As the scope of abuse over the history of the diocese became apparent to Archbishop Valery Vienneau of Moncton, then the bishop of Bathurst, he hired retired Supreme Court judge Michel Bastarache to lead a conciliation process in which victims would be encouraged to tell their stories to Bastarache and the judge would independently investigate and decide on a reasonable offer of compensation.
The diocese would pay for the process, would provide Bastarache with access to its personnel files and archives and the bishop would offer an apology on behalf of Bathurst Catholics.
The process largely avoided lawyers and headed off the drawn out and costly course of a class-action suit. Victims were free to turn down the offer and pursue their cases in court, but most chose the non-confrontational process with Bastarache. The diocese eventually paid $4.29 million to survivors.
Aviva claimed it was not bound by the insurance agreement it had with the diocese to pay any share of the compensation.
“Our hearts go out to the victims of sexual abuse in the Diocese of Bathurst,” Aviva said in a statement released after losing its appeal.
“Aviva fully supports payment of compensation to all those victimized by former priests of the Diocese of Bathurst. This court case was not about taking care of the victims of sexual abuse.”
While Aviva supports the diocese seeking reconciliation with victims, the company does not think it should pay for compensation decided by a process that advertised for and invited as many victims as possible to come forward.
“This court case was about reimbursing the Catholic Church for voluntary payments it made to victims of crimes perpetrated by its former priests. The church should not be insured for amounts paid voluntarily for reasons that have nothing to do with insurance coverage. The church sought insurance coverage for crimes committed by their priests, which evidence shows they attempted to cover up. That is wrong.”
Justice Marc Richard has a different view.
“Aviva knew it was ensuring a religious entity, which had broad obligations to its parishioners and the public,” Richard wrote in his decision. “Thus, the fact the conciliation process allowed the diocese to seek forgiveness and reconciliation, while at the same time ensuring its financial viability, would not have come as a surprise to the insurer.”
Nobody is denying that attempts were made to cover up priestly abuse in the past, Father Wesley Wade, Bathurst vicar general, told The Catholic Register. The conciliation process was an attempt to own up to victims and put the history of secrecy and cover-ups firmly in the past, he said.
“We did what we could,” said Father Wade. “We said, we’ll do kind of a process. We’ll be innovative in a way.”
The Bathurst conciliation process has since been taken up by the Archdiocese of Moncton, where Bishop Vienneau became archbishop in 2012.
“Our concern was for the victims,” said Father Wade. “What can we do for the victims? Because we’re responsible. We had to take on our responsibility.”
After taking on the first few cases, Aviva soon abandoned the diocese, said Father Wade.
“We did everything we could to have them join with us in these cases. They never did,” he said.
“A conciliation process was not only a financially responsible choice but also a financially necessary one,” Richard wrote in a unanimous decision of the appeal court.
“The diocese’s logic was that, if they advertised for victims and resolved claims through conciliation, they would minimize costs as much as possible and resolve claims in an efficient manner. The conciliation process was, in the main, about being pragmatic.”
By avoiding a class-action case, the diocese likely dodged bankruptcy, Father Wade said.
“The diocese’s additional purpose of seeking forgiveness and reconciliation does not render the conciliation process unreasonable,” said Richard.
The French-speaking Diocese of Bathurst serves a population of just over 94,000 Catholics in 15 parishes.